Talk:Brenda Walsh/@comment-70.29.236.203-20160207090109/@comment-27262712-20160701205424

Hi! You're right, I think there's conflicting info in the series (unless we're supposed to assume that Dylan can't correctly remember/doesn't care when Brenda's birthday is).

In Necessity Is a Mother, Brenda tells Iris that she's a Scorpio. But, as you mention, there is the emerald birthstone line in Dylan's daydream of his respective futures with Kelly and Brenda. If we're going on the assumption that Brenda herself declaring her sign is the most reliable source, she and Brandon are Scorpios :)